Neutrogena
Collagen Bank Face Moisturiser
sunscreen · 50 ml · 19 ingredients
£16.66−33%Amazon UK
- Fragrance-free
- No essential oils
- With glycerin
- With peptides
- With shea butter
Brand comparison · Beauty Comparison
Neutrogena vs Olay Sunscreens: Ingredients Compared (2026)
Neutrogena vs Olay sunscreens, compared by full ingredient list: 83% of Neutrogena's 6 and 17% of Olay's 6 are fragrance-free, and the cleanest list of the two brands belongs to Neutrogena Collagen Bank Face Moisturiser. Compared November 6, 2026.
The catch: Olay uses labelled fragrance allergens far more often (17% free vs 100%), so check that line if it matters to you.
Brand against brand, flag by flag
| Share of sunscreens that are… | Neutrogena (6) | Olay (6) | Ahead |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fragrance-free | 83% | 17% | Neutrogena |
| No essential oils | 100% | 67% | Neutrogena |
| No labelled fragrance allergens | 100% | 17% | Neutrogena |
| No drying alcohol | 100% | 100% | Tie |
| Sulfate-free | 100% | 100% | Tie |
| Silicone-free | 17% | 17% | Tie |
| Paraben-free | 100% | 100% | Tie |
| No MI/MCI | 100% | 100% | Tie |
The best of each brand
Each brand's two strongest lists by our ingredient rules.
Neutrogena
Ultra Gentle Daily Facial Moisturiser SPF30
sunscreen · 100 ml · 20 ingredients
£20.99Amazon UK
- Fragrance-free
- No essential oils
- With niacinamide
- With glycerin
- With panthenol
Olay
Complete Moisturise & Glow Face & Neck Lotion SPF15 Sensitive
sunscreen · 100 ml · 34 ingredients
£4.00−50%Amazon UK
- Fragrance-free
- No essential oils
- With niacinamide
- With glycerin
- With panthenol
Olay
Vitamin C Face Moisturiser Day Cream SPF30
sunscreen · 50 ml · 31 ingredients
£10.77−64%Amazon UK
- No essential oils
- With niacinamide
- With glycerin
- With vitamin C
Amazon UK prices as of 6 November 2026, 04:30 GMT; Amazon sets the final price at checkout.
Which brand suits your need
Fragrance-free
Neutrogena: 5 · Olay: 1 that pass every rule. Best fit: Neutrogena Collagen Bank Face Moisturiser.
Free of essential oils
Neutrogena: 5 · Olay: 1 that pass every rule. Best fit: Neutrogena Collagen Bank Face Moisturiser.
Sulfate-free
Neutrogena: 6 · Olay: 6 that pass every rule. Best fit: Neutrogena Collagen Bank Face Moisturiser.
Silicone-free
Neutrogena: 1 · Olay: 1 that pass every rule. Best fit: Neutrogena Collagen Bank Face Moisturiser.
Paraben-free
Neutrogena: 6 · Olay: 6 that pass every rule. Best fit: Neutrogena Collagen Bank Face Moisturiser.
Free of drying alcohol
Neutrogena: 6 · Olay: 6 that pass every rule. Best fit: Neutrogena Collagen Bank Face Moisturiser.
Sensitive skin
Neutrogena: 5 · Olay: 1 that pass every rule. Best fit: Neutrogena Collagen Bank Face Moisturiser.
Eczema-prone skin
Neutrogena: 5 · Olay: 1 that pass every rule. Best fit: Neutrogena Collagen Bank Face Moisturiser.
Every sunscreen from both brands
AffiliateFrequently asked questions
Is Neutrogena or Olay better for sensitive skin?
5 of Neutrogena's and 1 of Olay's sunscreens pass our sensitive-skin rules (no fragrance, essential oils, drying alcohol or MI). The strongest fit is Neutrogena Collagen Bank Face Moisturiser.
Which sunscreens are fragrance-free, Neutrogena or Olay?
5 of 6 Neutrogena and 1 of 6 Olay sunscreens list no parfum or fragrance, going by their full ingredient lists checked November 6, 2026.
People search this as “neutrogena vs olay”. More: all brand comparisons · how we pick.