Beauty Comparison
Shop by need
Eczema-prone skinRosacea-prone skinSensitive skinFragrance-freePerfume allergyAcne-prone skinFungal acnePsoriasisPregnancyDry skin
Buying guides
Fragrance-Free MoisturizersMoisturizers for Sensitive SkinMoisturizers for Acne-Prone SkinFragrance-Free CleansersFragrance-Free SunscreensFragrance-Free ShampoosCleansers for Sensitive SkinCleansers for EczemaCleansers for Acne-Prone SkinSunscreens for Sensitive Skin
Products
SkincareHaircareMakeupBodySun careMen's groomingBabyNailsFragranceTools
Ingredients
Tools
Free-from finderIngredient checkerBrand comparisons
Learn
SkincareHaircareMakeupNails, Body & FragranceHormones & Wellbeing
USCAUKDEFRITESNLPLSE

Brand comparison · Beauty Comparison

Catrice vs Essence Mascaras: Ingredients Compared (2026)

Catrice vs Essence mascaras, compared by full ingredient list: 100% of Catrice's 10 and 100% of Essence's 19 are fragrance-free, and the cleanest list of the two brands belongs to Catrice Glam & Doll Sculpt & Volume Mascara. Compared November 6, 2026.

The catch: the two brands are close on every flag we check, so pick by the product, not the brand.

Brand against brand, flag by flag

Share of mascaras that are…Catrice (10)Essence (19)Ahead
Fragrance-free100%100%Tie
No essential oils100%100%Tie
No labelled fragrance allergens100%100%Tie
No drying alcohol100%95%Catrice
Sulfate-free100%100%Tie
Silicone-free90%74%Catrice
Paraben-free90%100%Essence
No MI/MCI100%100%Tie

The best of each brand

Each brand's two strongest lists by our ingredient rules.

Affiliate

Which brand suits your need

Every mascara from both brands

Affiliate
ProductFragranceEssential oilsLabelled fragrance allergensDrying alcoholSulfatesSiliconesBuy
Catrice Glam & Doll Sculpt & Volume MascaraAmazon
Catrice Glam&Doll False Lashes MascaraAmazon
Catrice Hyper Lash MascaraAmazon
Catrice Lash Brow Designer Shaping And Conditioning Mascara GelAmazon
Catrice Lashes To Kill Waterproof Volume MascaraAmazon
Catrice Glam & Doll Easy Wash Off Power Hold Volume MascaraAmazon
Catrice Glam&Doll Curl & Volume MascaraAmazon
Catrice Pure Volume Magic Brown MascaraAmazon
Catrice Allround Mascara Ultra BlackAmazon
Catrice LIFT UP Volume & Lift Mascara Power Hold WaterproofAmazon
Essence All Eyes On Me Waterproof MascaraAmazon
Essence Get Big! Lashes Curl Boost MascaraAmazon
Essence Get Big! Lashes Volume Curl MascaraAmazon
Essence I love extremeAmazon
Essence I love extreme Crazy VolumeAmazon
Essence Lash PRINCESS sculpted volume mascaraAmazon
Essence Lash Without Limits Brown Extreme Lengthening & Volume MascaraAmazon
Essence Lash Without Limits Extreme Lengthening & Volume MascaraAmazon
Essence The False Lashes Mascara Extreme Volume & CurlAmazon
Essence Lash PRINCESS false lash effect mascara black brownAmazon
Essence What The Fake! Volumizing & Lengthening MascaraAmazon
Essence Bye Bye Panda Eyes! Smudge-proof Volumizing And Defining MascaraAmazon
Essence Get Big! Lashes Volume Boost MascaraAmazon
Essence Get BIG! lashes volume boost waterproof mascaraAmazon
Essence I Love Extreme Volume Mascara WaterproofAmazon
Essence Lash PRINCESS false lash effect mascara EXTREME waterproofAmazon
Essence Lash PRINCESS slim brush long & curl mascara waterproofAmazon
Essence make me BROW eyebrow gel mascaraAmazon
Essence maximum DEFINITION waterproof volume mascaraAmazon

Frequently asked questions

Is Catrice or Essence better for sensitive skin?

10 of Catrice's and 18 of Essence's mascaras pass our sensitive-skin rules (no fragrance, essential oils, drying alcohol or MI). The strongest fit is Catrice Glam & Doll Sculpt & Volume Mascara.

Which mascaras are fragrance-free, Catrice or Essence?

10 of 10 Catrice and 19 of 19 Essence mascaras list no parfum or fragrance, going by their full ingredient lists checked November 6, 2026.

People search this as “catrice vs essence tubing mascara”. More: all brand comparisons · how we pick.